Skip to main content

What are rare earths and why are they so central to geopolitical dynamics

With Marco Minella, a professor in the Department of Chemistry, we address the issue also at the center of the much-debated agreement between Ukraine and Donald Trump’s United States
Article topics
Article by
6 min
Mine

In recent days, there has been frequent talk of rare earths, especially in connection with an agreement between Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky and US President Donald Trump, which would grant the United States access to and exploitation of mineral resources in exchange for military and economic support for Ukraine in the third year of the war following Russian aggression.

But what are rare earths, and why have they become so crucial as to be the focus of a wartime agreement? We discussed this with Marco Minella, professor in the Department of Chemistry. 

Professor, what are rare earths?

The term rare earths, using the official definition from IUPAC (International Union of Pure and Applied Chemistry), refers to a group of 17 elements made up of the 14 lanthanides, plus scandium and yttrium. The acronym REE (Rare Earth Elements) is commonly used to identify these elements. The term “rare earth” has historical value, since they were in fact first isolated in some decidedly uncommon mineral oxides. In reality, the average concentration of rare earths in the Earth's crust (with the exception of the very unstable promethium) is decidedly higher than that of many much better-known elements such as gold and platinum, which are about three orders of magnitude less abundant on the Earth's surface than rare earths. One characteristic of this class of elements is the similarity of their chemical properties, which for several years made their separation a challenge for chemists.

Why are they so important?

Their importance is mainly linked to their widespread use in high-tech industrial sectors and to their substantial irreplaceability within them. These sectors include, for example, the energy sector (particularly that linked to the exploitation of renewable resources), the military sector, electronics (for the production of TV screens, mobile phones, rechargeable batteries, lighting devices such as LEDs, lasers...) and also the medical field. An interesting example comes from the world of wind turbine production, which requires the use of permanent magnets: 100 g of magnets of this type, which contain rare earths (in this case neodymium and dysprosium), generate a magnetic field equivalent to that produced by 1 kg of permanent magnets that do not contain rare earths. The importance of these elements for the production of efficient wind turbines is therefore evident. One highly interesting use in the medical field is gadolinium, an essential component in contrast agents for nuclear magnetic resonance imaging. The use of such agents makes it possible to maximize the diagnostic capabilities of this important medical tool.

Why are rare earths so central to the economy, to the point of being a crucial factor in geopolitical arrangements? 

Rare earths are essential for producing cutting-edge technology, thus providing the opportunity to excel in key sectors of the global industry. Having access to these elements is therefore of crucial geopolitical importance and, above all, allows the few producer countries to exert leverage over all those advanced economies that require large quantities of them to support and maintain their current technological level. The main feature of rare earths that makes them so interesting (and geopolitically crucial) is that while their concentration is relatively high on average across the Earth, their distribution is extremely uneven, with a few large deposits concentrated in a very small number of states (primarily China).

Which countries have the largest rare earth reserves? 

The largest rare earth reserves are held by China; Chinese reserves are estimated at 44,000,000 tons, with an extraction capacity that in 2024 reached 270,000 tons per year. By comparison, US reserves are estimated at 1,900,000 tons with annual extraction on the order of 45,000 tons. Other countries with significant reserves are Brazil (21,000,000 tons, currently still barely exploited), Australia (5,700,000 tons), India (6,900,000 tons), Myanmar (data not available), Russia (3,800,000 tons), and Vietnam (3,500,000 tons). It is interesting, for example, to note that Greenland has estimated reserves of 1,500,000 tons, not so far from current US reserves. These days there is also talk of the potential reserves in the Ukrainian subsoil, which are the basis of a possible agreement between the American administration and embattled Ukraine.

Are there rare earth deposits in Italy? Is it possible to imagine a revival of the Italian mining sector? 

Italy does not have significant rare earth reserves, especially when compared with the reserves of the countries mentioned above. There is often talk of a possible revival of the Italian mining sector, which in the past was in fact an important sector for our economy. I cannot claim to be an expert in the mining sector, so I will limit myself to a general observation. Italy is a densely populated country where the use of land must inevitably take into account immediate impacts on the population and impacts on an environmental and landscape heritage of vital importance to us and to our economy. For example, in the Beigua Natural Park in the province of Savona there is a deposit of titanium oxides (rutile) of great importance, whose exploitation must necessarily take into account the sensitivity of the environment in which it is located. Finding a balance between these conflicting needs is not always easy. Imagining a massive return of the mining sector as an economic driver for our country seems difficult at first glance. A different matter is developing a technologically advanced industry capable of recycling not only rare earths from waste, but also other critical materials. Discarded products and devices with a high technological content can, in this sense, become true resources.

What are the environmental impacts of rare earth extraction?

Large-scale mining activity is often associated with significant environmental impacts. The rare earth extraction industry is no exception. One major impact is on the health of workers operating at extraction sites, who, when overexposed to these elements, can develop even serious illnesses. Bioaccumulation effects of rare earths have also been observed, with the consequent development of significant diseases, in populations living near rare earth mining areas. An important environmental impact often affects the aquatic environment if water containing chemical reagents used for the extraction, processing, and recycling of rare earths (for example sulfates, oxalates, or extracting agents) is not properly treated. Another problem is associated with the presence of radioactive elements (such as thorium and uranium) within rare earth-bearing minerals. This aspect is perhaps the most critical in the world of rare earth extraction, since the residues produced can have residual radioactivity that is anything but negligible. Finally, the energy aspect linked to rare earth extraction must be considered, and in particular the significant release of climate-altering gases by this industrial sector. It is estimated that extracting 1 kg of samarium, europium, and gadolinium releases 55 kg of carbon dioxide into the atmosphere. This figure is significantly higher than the amount of CO₂ released during the extraction, for example, of 1 kg of copper, which is around 2.6 kg.