Skip to main content

The diary from COP31: climate at the tables, business at the stands

Armored streets, pavilions like display windows, science that becomes smaller but comes with a hefty price tag. Yet, being there still matters
Article topics
Article by
10 min
The COP31 plenary hall in Antalya
The COP31 plenary hall in Antalya (Chris McGrath/Getty Images)

By the time COP31 arrives, you’re already exhausted. The venue is about 25 kilometers from the center of Antalya and, between the shuttle and the tram, the trip never takes less than an hour each day. Many kilometers before the gates, the area is sealed off and effectively inaccessible. To get there, taxis take country roads, because the main arteries are watched by armed officers at every intersection. During the leaders’ summit it was even worse: the presidency had warned of “serious disruptions,” some roads were closed to let the heads of state and government process through, and the shuttles ran at reduced capacity all morning. I had seen nothing like it in Belém.

A different atmosphere

The atmosphere here is less “social” and less indigenous than in Belém. Antalya is much more serious: less civil society, much more commerce. I hope to see something different when Giorgio Brizio, our alumnus, joins me. But you don’t need to be an activist to understand that two games are being played here. On one side, the negotiations; on the other, another negotiation, one that has very little to do with politics.

The fact that politics and business go hand in hand is shown by the numbers. According to provisional UNFCCC data compiled by Carbon Brief, in-person registrations total 92,934, more than Dubai had in 2023. More than 14,000 are “host country guests,” a category never this large before.

Why people come here

And yet, and this is what struck me most, being here matters. Being able to say “I came here and said this, here” is worth more than a thousand emails and contacts built from afar. For those working in business, the logic is obvious: with decision-makers from almost every country in one place, especially those from developing countries, in one week you can do what would otherwise take years of travel, and back home you save a lot of money.

It’s not just true for businesses. It also applies to universities. In the WhatsApp group dedicated to Higher Education, you learn how to build connections between universities. That’s how I met Princess Abeer bin Farhan Al Saud, who invited me to a panel on a new initiative, GYCAN, which I’ll be keeping an eye on. And so, almost without meaning to, I became a speaker at an event full of young people and very young people. There I had the most human conversations of these days.

A session on work, business, and the electric transition at COP31 in Antalya
A session on work, businesses, and the electric transition (Abdullah Guclu/Anadolu via Getty Images)

The CEO’s Playground

Then there is what I now bluntly call the EXPO. Every year it gets worse: it really is a world exhibition, the CEOs’ playground. For me, though, it is essential: that is where you see who is there and who is not.

The universities are there. There are networks, the Network of Networks, that is, the university networks for sustainable development, and a few big organizations that can afford their own stand. But that is rare. And one absence surprised me: the pavilions entirely devoted to science have disappeared. In Belém there were spaces for planetary sciences and for science-informed policy, evidence-based policymaking. Here there is only one left, the one on the cryosphere. What is happening to climate science?

What is happening to science

In the corridors people talk about it, in hushed tones. The seventh IPCC report, AR7, is delayed and may not arrive in time for the second Global Stocktake in 2028. Governments cannot agree on the timeline, and the IPCC budget is suffering after Trump’s decision to halt U.S. contributions. But here on site I also heard another account, which I report as such: the delay would also stem from a lack of sources, because scientific publications from the Global South would overall be so few as to undermine the geographical balance of the literature on which the report is based. If even partly true, the lesson for us academics is clear: climate science is not global if half the world writes it. At the moment there are two main approaches. The short timeline is to publish the Report (in its three volumes) by 2028 in time for the second Global Stocktake. Governments cannot be asked to update climate targets without the latest scientific knowledge being made available. The longer timeline instead argues for a more extended schedule for at least two of the Report’s three volumes, in order to allow adequate time for scientific and governmental review, ensure the effective participation of scientists from countries with fewer resources, and not subordinate scientific work to diplomacy’s deadlines. On the other hand, if research timelines become too long, knowledge risks arriving when political decisions have already been made. That is why the publication date is not just a technical issue but also a profoundly political one.

The Earth’s energy balance

And yet, when science finds a room, it fills it. Today Johan Rockström, director of the Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research, presented “10 New Insights in Climate Science 2026/2027,” the report through which Future Earth, The Earth League and the World Climate Research Programme distill the latest research each year for negotiators. The first slide was literally a balance sheet: the Earth’s energy inventory. Since 1960 the planet has accumulated more than 400 zettajoules of extra heat, and almost all of it has gone into the oceans, especially the top 700 meters, but now also into the depths below 2,000 meters. The ocean is the great deposit account of global warming: it absorbs, and for that reason it makes us think the bill is smaller than it really is. I cannot resist asking Elisa Palazzi to explain what that means: “By absorbing about 91% of the excess energy trapped by the climate system due to the greenhouse effect amplified by human activities, the ocean stores heat that will continue to influence the climate for decades, representing a mortgage on future warming.”

Then there is the shape of the curve. Flat until the 1980s, it shoots up from the 1990s onward. Claudio Cassardo immediately replies: “It looks exponential.” But what does that mean? “Exponential growth does not increase at a constant rate, like linear growth, but doubles or increases proportionally over ever shorter time intervals. The graph clearly shows how, after a relatively stable trend up to the 1980s, the red curve (the total energy inventory) begins to rise steeply. The graph shows that the energy absorbed in the first 700 meters of the ocean is the main driver of this increase.”

The other red numbers follow the same logic: sea level accelerating, continents drying out, a 1.5 °C overshoot that keeps growing and will make us dependent on CO₂ removals.

Who pays the bill

As the accountant, I mainly noted the economic items. First: the social cost of carbon has been severely underestimated, and updated models put it up to four times higher, while in 2025 carbon prices in emissions markets and carbon taxes ranged from a few cents to under 180 dollars per ton, according to the World Bank. The price we pay is a fraction of the damage we cause. The second is a real deferred debt: according to Rockström, for an industry that emitted CO₂ in 1990, 90% of the economic damage is still to come. Carbon dioxide remains in the atmosphere for a long time, and the bill arrives in later fiscal years.

Then there is the frontier of attribution, which links damage to those who caused it. The carbon majors, that is, the fossil-fuel industry and cement producers, would be responsible for half of the increase in the intensity of heatwaves since the industrial era and for between 25 and 40% of sea-level rise. The 50,000 Europeans who died prematurely in this summer’s heatwave, Rockström said, can be traced back to the fossil industry. And the slide was not speaking in abstractions: it showed the names of the oil and gas and cement companies that weigh most heavily on those chilling results.

Silvana Dalmazzone says, here with me in Antalya: “Seeing the names of companies next to climate damage makes responsibilities concrete that would otherwise remain diluted in global statistics. Scientific attribution does not automatically amount to legal responsibility, but it can fuel litigation that entails legal costs, compensation risks and reputational consequences for companies. It is already happening. And it strengthens the case for more ambitious carbon pricing policies: the price of emissions must quickly come to fully reflect the damage they cause. In Europe, the ETS is moving in this direction, albeit with gradual mechanisms needed to allow the economic system to adapt and to contain the effects on energy costs. It is a tool that must absolutely be defended against the pressure now emerging to weaken it. And it must be accompanied by measures and investments that make cleaner technologies accessible and improve quality of life, protecting the most exposed families and the most fragile areas from the costs of the transition.”

For those working on accountability, this is a turning point: responsibility finally has a name and an address. And there is also good news, which negotiators would do well not to forget: a package of interventions on food systems would yield a welfare gain equal to 7% of current GDP.

The denial of delay

Then came the passage that struck me most. Climate denial had its peaks in Kyoto in 1997 and on the eve of Copenhagen in 2009, and today it is at a new peak. But it is a different kind of denial: it no longer challenges science, it postpones. The latest insight, on a just transition and geopolitics, asks whether the instability of the world will speed up the phaseout of fossil fuels or slow it down. In Antalya, for now, the answer seems to be the latter.

Al Gore, at a side event in an almost wooded setting, added his own preacher-like flavour. The real brake in developing countries is the cost of capital, and 2026 will be remembered as the year when the Atlantic circulation, the Gulf Stream, began to weaken. “The best incredible truth of science.”

Greta Thunberg speaks at COP31 in Antalya alongside Rikki Dank, representative of the Gudanji and Wakaya Indigenous peoples
Greta Thunberg speaks alongside Rikki Dank, representative of the Gudanji and Wakaya Indigenous peoples (Burak Kara/Getty Images)

Greta, who speaks little

And then there is Greta Thunberg, back at a COP for the first time since Glasgow 2021. She is extremely reserved: no mob scenes, very few appearances. But when she speaks, she does not hold back. Upon arriving in Antalya, she called it “hypocrisy” that every year the host countries have the chance to clean up their image, in negotiations “full of lobbyists paid precisely by destructive industries.” Today, in her speech in Antalya, she went further: the planet “is not dying, it is being killed, and we know who,” “the same people we thought would come to save us.” One may disagree with the tone. But after a morning spent among the EXPO stands, it is hard not to agree with her on the second point, and on the denial of delay.

Provisional balance sheet

Anyone who deals with accounting knows that halfway through the fiscal year you do not close the books: you prepare a provisional statement. Mine, for now, says this. On the asset side, the strength of being together: decision-makers, universities and young people in the same place, conversations that no video call can replace. On the liability side, a more closed, more commercial COP, with science reduced to one pavilion and civil society to a few corridors. We will see the balance next week, when the final texts are written. In the meantime, the appointment is with Giorgio’s взгляд, and with the uncomfortable questions he will bring with him.

related content

COP31 at the Antalya Expo Center

Road to Antalya, diary from COP31: excited, but at 35%

The UN climate conference kicks off in Turkey. My second COP from the inside, first lesson: the teachers are there, you just need to know where to look for them. And on the table, a word we’ll hear until we’re sick of it: electrification
by
Laura Corazza
Read more su Road to Antalya, diary from COP31: excited, but at 35%