The diary from COP31, the return: why climate science needs allies
I’m writing from Turin, with my suitcase still unpacked. I came back before the end because, as we know, professors also have to teach (just kidding!): in Antalya, at this very moment, the final texts are being written and the cover decision document is finally online. I left COP with two recordings on my phone, which I listened to several times. I want to close this diary from there, from two voices that put climate science back at the center of the room. We leave UniTo in Giorgio (Brizio)’s hands.
A ship without a rudder
The first voice is that of Jim Skea, chair of the IPCC. Because I was in that room too, seated at that table. Don’t ask me how, but they needed company, so I sat down right in front of him. He began by echoing the image chosen for the opening of the conference: “Climate action without science is like a ship without a rudder. And I stand by that statement.” Then he laid out the facts, one after another. The remaining carbon budget is almost exhausted. The effects of warming are no longer a projection: “For many of us” they remain images in a video, “but for many communities, especially the most vulnerable, they are a lived reality.” Beyond 1.5°C, the “glowing ember” diagrams with which the IPCC represents risks turn increasingly red. And the rising sea will remain irreversible for centuries, if not millennia.
The most scientific passage, and also the most honest, was the one on overshoot. Only deep, rapid and lasting cuts across all sectors would stop warming at a peak of 1.7–1.8°C, bringing it back to 1.5°C by the end of the century. “That’s what our scientists are telling me now: temporary overshoot, peak and decline.” Immediately after, however, came a sentence few leaders would have the courage to say: “Science still does not have all the answers about overshoot.” That sentence was especially moving, even with a touch of emotion on his part. We do not know precisely how the Earth system will respond to CO₂ removal. A rough estimate says that removing about 220 gigatonnes would lower the temperature by a tenth of a degree. And nothing guarantees that the road back will retrace the road out.
Then the sentence I keep with me: “Extinct species will not come back just because global warming is reversed.” There are losses that no later correction can undo, and the longer we stay above the threshold, the more of them accumulate. That is why the delay in the seventh IPCC report is not a procedural detail. A report that arrives late is a rudder that does not respond.
Guterres’ last COP
The second voice is that of António Guterres, at his last COP as secretary-general. On November 13 I listened to him live, and it was the most moving, and most emotional, speech of my two COPs. “You cannot promise young people a better future while destroying the natural systems on which that future depends. And you cannot speak seriously of justice when those who did least to cause the crisis suffer first and most.” Then came the sharpest point: “The injustice is even deeper, because we know what is happening, we know what is causing it, and we know what we must do.” Fossil fuels are driving the crisis, and an accelerated phase-out is needed, “just, orderly and equitable.”
He too began with the science. Exceeding 1.5°C is now unavoidable; our responsibility is to make sure that overshoot is “as small as possible, for as short a time as possible,” and to bring temperatures back below the threshold as soon as possible. Emissions cuts of around 6% a year would be needed. With current commitments, instead, we are headed for “an overshoot as far as the eye can see,” around 2.5°C by the end of the century: “a recipe for catastrophe.”
The moment that moved me most, though, came later, when he responded to those asking about his tone. “I do not consider myself someone who speaks too bluntly. I simply say what is true.” He was coming out of a meeting with civil society and spoke of a growing awareness, in public opinion and in several governments and institutions: we have to do more, and we are still on a path toward disaster. He reserved “enormous respect” for the IPCC, while not hiding how much geopolitical divisions weigh on the next report. I confess I was moved.
Two words with Johan Rockström
I was walking through this utterly fake park inside the COP venue and then, with the same attitude as the schoolgirls in the front row for Indiana Jones, I went straight up to him. Johan Rockström. We chatted and he told me a few things. Talking about the Earth’s average temperature, he tells me that up to 1900 the line is flat; then it starts to rise and from 2000 onward it accelerates: today we gain 0.27 °C every ten years, more than twice the pace of the late twentieth century. Global warming, in short, is not just continuing: it is speeding up. The second is a check-up. Just as a doctor looks at a patient’s fever and blood pressure, scientists track sixteen climate “vital signs”: seven are at their worst recorded values ever. He points me to the Global Carbon Budget 2026 (Friedlingstein et al.), which for an accountant is the most eloquent, because it is a real balance sheet. Above zero, the CO₂ we emit, from fossil fuels and deforestation. Below zero, where it ends up: partly absorbed by oceans and forests, the rest accumulates in the atmosphere. And the numbers do not quite add up: there remains a discrepancy that scientists are still studying, and they show it clearly in a graph. For a university like ours, these are concrete ideas on which to act and build strategy in the years ahead. And to be convinced, I recommend the conversation with Johan Rockström published by Otto’s Instagram channel.
Learning from other universities
My most personal takeaway, though, comes from the Higher Education meetings, which I attended several times. Not representational events, but genuine opportunities to improve. I’m taking away a few ideas.
The first is a commitment to the responsible use of artificial intelligence: a pledge that asks universities to reflect on how AI enters research, teaching, and management, and how much it consumes. The second is the university as a sustainability living lab: the campus as a laboratory in which to experiment, measure, and report on what we teach. The third came on November 13, when the European Commission, with Wellcome and nine public funders from five continents, launched the first global alliance of research funders on climate and health. Of research, then.
On Friday, November 13, we also brought the COP to our students with a livestream for UniTo, while the negotiations were underway. This was made possible thanks to Jacopo Bencini, Andrea Grieco, and Antonio Piemontese, and to the immense willingness of Emanuele Bompan. The questions coming from Turin showed that the COP can be explained, and that there are people who want to listen to it.
Chill out in Antalya
In my second piece I had lamented the absence of civil society. Saturday’s climate march partly proved me wrong, and I’m glad of it. Walking around the city after the demonstration was moving: many people kept telling me that, in Turkey, something like this is by no means a given. I was checked twice, without any tension, as normally happens. I had the feeling I had seen something precious and fragile. It was a pleasure here to meet up again with Giorgio Brizio in Antalya, with his attentive eye on rights and our conversations about “futures.”
Perhaps that is the lesson of Antalya: we need to learn how to live COPs. They are not just the realm of the bad lobby, which does exist. One can take part positively, bringing knowledge and receiving it, to improve ourselves together. Climate is a problem that is collaborative by nature: no one solves it alone. And the COP should be used for what it can be: the largest space for collaboration we have.
So I leave you with more than I thought I would have to my credit: an IPCC chair who has the honesty to say what science still does not know, a secretary-general who calls what he says truth, and not courage, universities learning from one another, a city that took to the streets. As I finish, Italian Climate Network reports on the closed-door meeting between civil society and EU heads of delegation. The stalemate on the AR7 also worries Brussels, which has asked civil society for concrete proposals to break it. It is an invitation universities should not let pass: climate science needs allies, not spectators. The helm, Skea would say, is there. The course is up to us.
P.S. The first comments on the draft released less than an hour ago include one aspect that is very interesting to us… the dialogue between mountains and climate.